14 Comments

Please keep doing these forever

Expand full comment

Hy guys!

do you know that the FUTURA font (which is German) is the one used by many railway companies for their signs and communication? I think Donald knew...

Expand full comment
Nov 3Liked by Mac Barnett

I ran to the library to get this book, and I immediately read it with my 6 year old. Just a couple of pages in, she whispers, "Oh no..." Just perfect.

Expand full comment

Donald Crews’ love for trains is so real. Big, fast, cool different cars, special sounds, colors. I bet he had some cool train toys too 🚂 This book is a THRILLER

Expand full comment

I may be reaching, but maybe “short-cut” is being used here to indicate that their lives could have been “cut short”?

Expand full comment

I love the way Crews uses the 'We' and the typeface not just to show the collective decision, but as part of the design too. The first spread where they are making the decision, the lines of text move left and right as he changes the indent, almost as you would look left and right and all around before choosing your path and setting out. Then for the rest of the story each line is slightly indented and he uses the w in 'We' at the beginning of many lines with the increasing indent to emphasize moving forward, except in the moment of indecision - "We should have taken the road" where it is positioned without an indent, and in the very last line, where the position and slope of the A in "And we never took the short-cut again" completely contrasts the direction of the preceding indented lines, all starting with W. Very cool to see the typography incorporated into the design of the graphic spreads in this way.

Expand full comment

I was wondering if Shortcut was too scary for my toddler, but then I remembered he loves The Skull, which itself has a thrilling sequence with a repetitive threat

Expand full comment

I just wanted to share my favorite Halloween book: Hester by Byron Barton. A little witch in a big city.

Expand full comment

Love getting recommendations from y’all! Definitely adding to our list. You had me at scary. as. hell.

Expand full comment

I SO enjoyed the book through your discussion ( I bought it and read it beforehand).

I felt the need to listen to 1990s American trains on youtube to know if I’d been making the right ‘Whoo whoos’ as I read it out loud, ( British trains sounded different I think!)

A really wonderful book.

Expand full comment

I absolutely LOVED hearing you guys read and discuss this book at Picture Book Summit (especially when Mac said to Jon, “… It’s a TRAIN!” in response to Jon’s owl-influenced “WOO-WOOs.”) I’m curious though - do you think this book would get published today? I notice that a lot of the books you share are from your own childhoods, which is lovely… yet I am also keenly aware of how industry standards have changed in recent years and often find myself wondering “could this be published today?” I’d love to know your thoughts on that… and whether your focus on these older classics has anything to do with that?

Expand full comment

I never knew about this book- so glad to learn about it! The multiple page sequences with no text made me think of David Wiesner's books which we fell in LOVE with when a bookstore employee recommended them to me for my toddler son (who is now in college). We cherished reading them together many times across his childhood. I hope you'll consider doing a post on Flotsam, Free Fall, or Sector 7, our absolute favorites- all do so much with illustration & little/no text.

Expand full comment

First of all, I am so excited about a place to unabashedly nerd out over picture books. I love everything about this Substack. My 4 kids are older now (youngest is 13), but we discovered Shortcut at a library in WV many years ago. It became my kids’ favorite read aloud so we bought our own used copy. Mac and Jon have brought forward so many brilliant aspects of this book. Definitely a masterpiece.

Expand full comment

This was so good. I had to wonder about whether they had been told about someone having a terrible accident walking the rails in the past, and so they realized what could have happened, and the risk they took, and why they would never tell mamma and bigmamma. Where was pappa, and big pappa…??

Expand full comment